Uncertain Futures: Dombrowski Signals Change for Two Phillies Players
In his end-of-season press conference, Dave Dombrowski delivered pointed–though non-committal–remarks regarding the 2026 status of two Phillies players, making clear that while they remain under contract, their fits with the roster are not assured.
The Players and the Situation
Nick Castellanos
Castellanos, the veteran outfielder, has one year remaining on his five-year, $100 million contract (2026 being the final year). His 2025 season was marked by diminished performance values and public tensions with manager Rob Thomson.
Phillies Nation
Breaking
When asked if Castellanos will be back in 2026, Dombrowski responded:
“Well, we’ll see what happens… I’m not going to get into specific players that are on our roster under contract.”
Breaking AC
Coupled with Castellanos’ self-admitted dissatisfaction and the club’s stated interest in other outfield options, the implication is that while nothing is finalized, his role moving forward is questionable.
Phillies Nation
Bryce Harper
Harper is not explicitly one of the two players Dombrowski referenced as “won’t be with the team,” but his future was similarly assessed. Dombrowski said that while Harper is “still a quality player,” the question is whether he can return to his “elite” stature.
The Washington Post
Though Harper remains under contract through 2031, the tone suggests the organization may be looking for structural flexibility and change within the roster beyond mere retention.
What This Means for 2026
Roster flexibility matters – With heavy contracts and aging talent, the Phillies appear willing to reconsider core pieces if alignment or performance falls short.
Signal of a potential transition – Dombrowski’s language (“we’ll see what happens”) is as close to public uncertainty as Philadelphia’s front-office often becomes. This suggests an openness to trade, benching, or role reduction for players who may not fit the competitive window as envisioned.
Not a guaranteed departure – Importantly, neither Castellanos nor Harper have been definitively ruled out. The remarks signal possibility rather than certainty, giving the Phillies flexibility as they evaluate the offseason.
Focus on younger/upgraded options – In discussing outfield options and roles, Dombrowski emphasized younger talent and alternative solutions, indicating a shift away from relying solely on veteran big-ticket contracts.
Inquirer.com
A Closer Look: Castellanos’ Case
His 2025 campaign: a diminished batting average (.250) and an OPS (.694) well below expectations.
Inquirer.com
Disputes with the manager and reduced everyday playing time cast doubt on his long-term fit.
Phillies Nation
With one year remaining on his deal, the Phillies have trade leverage: move him now (potentially eating salary) or carry him into 2026 with the question of role satisfaction.
Dombrowski’s public acknowledgment that discussions and internal resolutions took place signals he is actively evaluating the landscape rather than simply letting contracts play out.
Leave a Reply